Movement One — The Narrator Admits Something
I should tell you, before anything else, that I am not a fair judge of this story. I have never claimed to be. I am the one telling it, which means I get to decide where it starts, whose face you see first, and whose grief gets a name and whose doesn't. That is a kind of power, and I am not going to pretend it isn't.
So let me be honest about the part of me that isn't honest at all: I have a great deal of empathy, more than most souls I have ever met in this gray, patient world, and empathy is a strange thing to carry into a story about people I am about to call bad. Greed is not rare here. It is not rare anywhere, in Something or in Nothing, in the living world or the dead one — I have watched it dress itself in a thousand different masks, some of them almost convincing. Some souls wear the mask so well you'd swear there was nothing underneath it but ordinary hunger, forgivable hunger, the kind everyone carries a little of. Others let it slip, and you see the whole shape of what they are, and you cannot unsee it.
I don't carry much of that hunger myself. I might be lying about that. I might not be. This story is being told from where I stand, and I have no way of proving to you that where I stand is honest ground. All I can offer you is the account, and let you decide, the way you always do, whether the narrator deserves your trust.
Now. The circus.
If you asked anyone who has spent long enough in Ilyrisse's stretch of the Between which souls have learned, more or less, how to behave — which factions keep their hands where the Empress of Eternity can see them, which don't test the size of her patience — most would tell you the circus is the answer. Not because they are gentle. They are not gentle. Because they are, in their own colorful, ridiculous, unsettling way, obedient. They have learned exactly how far the leash extends, and for a long time now they have stayed inside it.
It wasn't always so.
Before Ilyrisse claimed this stretch of gray as hers — properly claimed it, the way a queen claims a kingdom rather than simply passing through it — the circus was a pack of scavengers. They preyed on weak souls, the newly arrived, the ones who hadn't yet learned to hold a shape or protect what little they'd built for themselves, and if a soul carried anything worth taking — a memory-shaped trinket, a scrap of power, the fragile beginning of an identity — the circus took it, if the reward looked good enough to justify the trouble. It didn't happen to many. Only to the small handful of souls who wandered too close to their little house, which wasn't a house at all, not really. It was a fragment of a world, a proper pocket of Something folded into the gray, small as fragments go but real in every way that mattered, and it looked, of all things, like a circus. Hence the name. I suppose, to stay faithful to the fragment they carried with them, they dressed the part — clowns, all of them, with the paint and the ruffled collars and the shoes too big for anyone's feet.
If you stumble upon this narrative on Amazon, it's taken without the author's consent. Report it.
It sounds almost funny, put that way. The people who wear the paint are not funny at all.
I could call them evil. Malevolent. Ignorant, greedy, whatever word you like best — the kind of group most souls would agree deserves the label "bad" without needing much convincing. But I am not most souls. I am the narrator, and I try, as a rule, not to hand out labels I haven't earned the right to use. Greed belongs to everyone who has ever existed, in some measure. Some wear the mask well enough that you never see under it. Others don't manage that trick at all, and it is a strange, uncomfortable thing to watch, the ones who can't keep the greed hidden and the ones who can, standing side by side as if there weren't an ocean of difference between them. Even Eremos carries some of it, somewhere, I imagine — though if he does, he has buried it so deep under everything else he is that I doubt even he could find it on purpose.
For what it's worth, I don't think I carry much of it myself. I have a great deal of empathy and very little appetite, which is either a virtue or the world's cruelest joke, depending on which day you ask me. I might be lying. This story is mine to tell, and you have no way of checking my math.
Consider, for a moment, what it actually means to be a narrator in a world like this one. I was not there for every private thought that crossed Vesalia's mind on the plain that day, nor for the particular calculus Ilyrisse ran behind her folded arms before she decided what to do with fifteen broken clowns. I have simply been told enough, by enough of the people who were there, and have watched enough of what this world does to the people who live in it, that I can stitch the gaps together with something close enough to truth that the difference stops mattering. That is what telling a story always is, in the end, whether the teller admits it or not. I am choosing, admitting it plainly, rather than pretending the seams don't show.
It matters, I think, that you understand this before we go any further, because the circus is not a story about villains getting what they deserved. It is a story about a kingdom, and the particular, unglamorous work of holding one together — the slow accumulation of a thousand small decisions about who gets folded into your keeping and who gets let loose to become someone else's problem, who gets a cell with its senses intact and who gets the mercy of numbness instead. Ilyrisse has been making those decisions for longer than most souls in the Between have existed at all. This was simply the day one of them happened to intersect with someone I love telling you about.
To the circus, I imagine, I am the villain of this account, the way any narrator becomes the villain to the people whose worst day he chooses to describe. And to me — to the story I am telling you — they are the villains too, in their own turn. It sounds tangled, I know. It won't stay tangled for long. Not once you understand what Ilyrisse did, that ordinary day, to keep them in line.
We have spoken of many people already in the telling of this world, and Ilyrisse is far from an exception. But what do we actually know of her? That she is beautiful — devastatingly so, though I won't spend too long dwelling on it, she doesn't need the narrator's flattery on top of everything else she carries. That she holds a kingdom the size of a small world. That her fragment shelters thousands, and grows new corners of itself the way a living thing grows new branches, without her ever quite noticing it happening.
Setting all of that aside — let's talk about what she did, that ordinary day, to keep the circus in line.